21 Dec Lender Denied Attorneys Fees in Bankruptcy Claim
Mortgage documents must expressly give the lender attorneys fees in bankruptcy proceedings, a Kansas bankruptcy court judge ruled this week disallowing U.S. Bank Home Mortgage its attorneys fees. General provisions for fees to protect the lender’s rights in the property are not sufficient for bankruptcy fees.
To get fees added to the bankruptcy proof of claim, the creditor must prove 1) there is equity in the property, 2) the attorneys fees are reasonable and 3) the loan documents allow the fees, Judge Janice Miller Karlin ruled in In Re Tabares, 08-40324-13, (Bankr. D. Kan. December 15, 2008).
U.S. Bank relied on the â€œdo and pay whatever is necessary to protect the value of the Property and Lenderâ€™s rights in the Property,â€ language in the promissory note and mortgage to include $350 in attorneys fees in its proof of claim in the debtor’s chapter 13 bankruptcy proceeding, which fees Judge Karlin denied.
“Although the mortgage does state that U.S. Bank can â€œdo and pay whateverâ€ is necessary to protect its interest in the property, when that phrase is read together with other provisions of the contract, and with other documents executed during the transaction, it is clear to the Court that the most reasonable interpretation of paragraph 7 is that attorney fees are not included in the items to which U.S. Bank is entitled on a debt that has not yet been accelerated,” Judge Karlin ruled.
Jan Hamilton, Standing Chapter 13 Trustee for Topeka, Kansas, objected to the fees in the proof of claim. Cynthia Woolverton of Milsap & Singer, LLC, of St. Louis, MO, represented U.S. Bank.
Read more about bogus fees in chapter 13 claims in Bankruptfcy Law Network.
Latest posts by Jill Michaux (see all)
- Last Day to Comment on New Chapter 13 Plan, Petition, Schedules, Means Test, Bankruptcy Rules Changes - February 17, 2014
- Does Chapter 13 Mean Paying All Creditors Back? It Could Be Zero to Unsecured Claims - June 18, 2013
- Random Bankruptcy Audits Stopped - April 24, 2013
- What’s Baseball Got to Do with Bankruptcy? - March 31, 2013
- Bankruptcy Code Dollar Figures Raised 6.3% for Inflation - February 21, 2013