Click Here To Receive FREE Email Updates!

Current ArticleMain Content RSS FeedSubscribe

Massachusetts Courts Disagree on Bankruptcy Law Superceding Specific Federal Consumer Protections

Two Massachusetts courts disagree on whether bankruptcy laws supercede federal consumer protection statutes.  Ameriquest Mortg. Co. v. Nosek (In re Nosek), 354 B.R. 331 (D MA 2006) ruled that bankruptcy laws are all-encompassing and replace the other specific statutes, while Holland v. EMC Mortg. Co. (In re Holland), 2007 Bankr. LEXIS 3187 (Bankr D MA 2007) ruled otherwise.

There are a number of federal consumer protection laws, including Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA, Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), Truth in Lending Act (TILA), and Real Estate Settlement Practices Act (RESPA, also known as the Servicer Act, which actually is a subset of TILA).  There also is the very exensive Bankruptcy Code with its automatic stay (sanctions left to the court’s discretion) and claim objection procedures (facially simple but not so in practice when discovery is required). 

There are strong tactical and strategic reasons for exercising rights under the separate consumer protection statutes, including a debtor’s receipt of automatic disclosures upon simple request and automatic statutory damages - both obligations not existing in the Bankruptcy Code.  This author applauds Attorney David Baker, debtor’s counsel in the Holland case, for successfully resisting the Nosek ruling.

Get In Touch With A Lawyer Near You

Why are you considering bankruptcy?

Garnishment
Creditor Harassment
Repossession
Foreclosure
Lawsuits
Illness/Disability
Divorce
Other:

What kind of bill problems do you have?

Credit Cards / Store Cards
Personal Loans
Child Support
Student Loans
Car Loans
Income Taxes
Payday Loans
Medical/Dental/Hospital Bills
Past Due Mortgage Bills
Other:

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship with any lawyer, nor does it constitute an agreement by any lawyer to perform any service – including consult with you in any way. Some lawyers may charge a fee for a consultation concerning your situation. We will never sell your personal information.

Trackback URL

RSS Feed for This PostPost a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.