Bankruptcy’s Means Test and Special Circumstances
By L. Jed Berliner, Springfield Bankruptcy Attorney on Oct 5, 2007 in Bankruptcy Practice and Procedure, Chapter 7 Bankruptcy, Decisions of Interest, General Bankruptcy Information, Massachusetts, Surrendering Property
A bankruptcy judge can find that “special circumstances” exist to avoid the harsh impact of the Means Test now used in all above-median income cases.
Two days ago, I provided a very brief overview of the Means Test. I briefly summarized its three parts as: (1) Each debtor’s income for the six full months before filing (including a spouse’s income unless separated) is compared against the median income for the debtor’s household size in the home state; (2) An above-median income debtor’s income is tested against IRS allowances; and (3) Any excess is examined against the amount of debt this excess could pay over five years. I also noted that the IRS uses these allowances as discretionary guidelines for negotiating payments on tax debts, but Congress’ BAPCPA requires strict application for all above-median income debtors.
Cases to date have allowed special circumstances for separate households due to employment reasons, student loans, and unusually high but justifiable vehicle expenses. Cases have rejected special circumstances for high housing costs associated with an expensive suburb and its better schools, a zero percent dividend to unsecured creditors in an alternative Chapter 13 case, and a loss of income. Courts have gone both ways on 401(k) loan repayments. Many cases may be appealed, and different rulings on the same issues can occur in the future.
If you liked that post, then try these...
New Ammunition Against Creditor Abuse After Bankruptcy by Michael Doan
Jones v. Wells Fargo Administrative Order 2008-1 by Kevin Gipson, New Orleans Bankruptcy Attorney
When Do I Know Its Right To File For Bankruptcy? 5 Top Reasons. Part II of II. by Michael Doan
Credit Reports and Bankruptcy? by Carmen Dellutri, Attorney at Law
The Worst That Can Happen In A Bankruptcy by Douglas Jacobs, California Bankruptcy Attorney
You must be logged in to post a comment.